 |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
|
| |
| Time to Make Reform Our Issue |
 |
by David Mittman, PA - March 8, 2010
|
|
Provided by Clinician 1
It seems we PAs and NPs have given up. As you know, I am pretty straightforward about my feelings on many issues. Where have the NP and PA professions’ voices gone when it comes to national healthcare? Have we put our heads in the sand as the issue has become more partisan? More divisive? To me that’s not good enough. We have to be more vocal on this. Not that we can solve it, but we can keep calling for a better system and one that uses both our professions to their full potential.
The bottom line is we still need some sort of national health insurance, maybe even more than we did last year. Why? Politicians will tell you that “most people are happy with the insurance they have" – at least that’s what some want us to hear. Why change something that is not broken? I think most of us who provide care know it was broken before and still is. Remember the millions of families who have no insurance. They have not gone away. We forget that people won’t leave jobs, or start businesses, or take risks because they are afraid of losing the coverage they have. We forget the arguments we all have had with the insurance clerks.
Lately, something new has happened, which I think has not filtered down yet to the regular citizens or our elected representatives. Something which will be another huge reason for us to push for national healthcare. Employer-paid plans are slowly but surely being replaced by “defined contribution” plans. Simply, you will have to pay more and more, and your employer will pay less and less, for your coverage. When the increase in your payment goes up 20%, 30%, 40% every year, more people will revolt. Many will see what the real costs of care are and pay for a while. Some will not pay and even more will be added to the millions without.
Insurance companies are also reducing coverage while significantly raising costs. Some companies have stopped selling health insurance as they can’t keep up with the cost increases. My insurance agent said most companies are raising rates significantly to hedge their bets because there still is a chance that national healthcare passes in one fashion or another. Be sure, they will also keep charging us more, one way or another.
Again, look at the auto industry. One of the costs that doomed them was healthcare, both to retirees and their active workforce. Why has Canada gained so many auto plants? One reason, no healthcare costs. Which industries are next? Newspapers, and most of publishing in general, with their thin margins; airlines; sales jobs. These are the next who will drop all health coverage. There, again, will be large segments of the population who can’t afford to be covered. It’s only a matter of time.
I am very wary of any Federal “takeover” of healthcare. I know that it may take awhile to get it right. But I also know that talk of “death panels,” “socialism” and “let the insurance companies run healthcare” are scare tactics. People forget that with Medicare, Medicaid, social security disability, the military healthcare system and the VA, the Federal government is already a MAJOR player in healthcare. All of those agencies provide care – some better, some worse. Let’s see the people screaming “socialism” burn their Medicare cards – never happen. The Republicans really have no workable plan, and the Democrats have done a really poor job explaining their plan or why healthcare reform is critical for our future. To keep our economy strong. To keep all Americans healthy. Instead, we are back to “he said, she said” and no one is really moving us ahead.
So I say the question we have to help answer is this one: How do we cover and insure at a rate that is affordable to our citizens who have, or soon will have, no healthcare? I am scared of the Feds taking anything over but more scared of the insurance industry raising rates until no one has care.
PAs and NPs have a stake in this. If we really care about our own futures and the futures of our patients. Keep letting people know our feelings. Let your patients know. Let your elected officials know that the only way we will solve this is by all parties working TOGETHER. Enough partisanship on this one.
After all someone has to advocate for our country’s healthcare. As a real professional, take a minute and do so.

Dave has been a PA, and later NP, leader for thirty years. He strongly believes that NPs and PAs must work together to insure a better future for both professions. Most recently Dave has been busy launching another dream; Clinician 1, the first internet community for PAs and NPs. In October 2008, Dave was honored by the New Jersey State society of PAs with its “Lifetime Achievement Award”.
The viewpoint expressed in this article is the opinion of the author and is not necessarily the viewpoint of the owners or employees at Healthcare Staffing Innovations, LLC.
RECOMMEND THIS ARTICLE
You must be logged in to recommend articles

|
 |
 |
 |
| Jared |
on 10 Mar 2010 at 4:37 am |
|
Laura,
She went to the US because she knew waiting 3 years for cancer treatment in Canada may seriously affect her outcome, if not kill her. She also knew she'd have access to the best cancer specialists, diagnostic measures, remission indicators and PET scans, along with pharmaceutical and treatment plans that are groundbreaking, proven to work, and endless opportunities should 1 particular type of treatment fail. Yes, all this at the cost of the most expensive health care system/plan in the world. |
|
| Jared |
on 10 Mar 2010 at 4:32 am |
|
JoAnn,
You forgot to add that all people enrolled in Medicaid need to take urine drug tests to prove they are drug free to qualify and stay on the program, just as I had to take a urine drug test to be able to have a job and provide for people, make an income, only to pay taxes for medicaid programs that support those doing drugs/alcohol and abusing the system. |
|
| Patrick ((North Carolina)) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 9:39 pm |
|
Dave,
Thank you for the liberal commentary and undoubtedly non-biased opinion. As a provider on the front line...the Emergency Department I can tell you that I am tired of seeing people that can AFFORD to purchase health care but CHOOSE not too. Medicaid/Medicare is grossly abused...people that can't walk into their doctors office same day walk into an ED and the tax payers are charged 5 times the cost of a visit to a PMD's office. Medicaid cards are being used to obtain narcotics to be sold or abused as people are going from one ED to another. While I agree that something must be done I do not feel that this bill is the answer. I recall a certain President stumping on the campaign trail for transparency in gov't, "I will create a health care bill and C-Span will be there." Really....I didn't see C-Span at the Nebraska and Loiusiana deals did you or the other 300 million Americans? Lower the costs of increasing health care...Where is Tort reform in this 2000 page monstrosity!?
RESPONSIBILITY...This is the one term that Americans are lacking. We as a society have no responsibility. If you make $25K a year you do not need an expenisve purse, watch, car/truck, tattoos etc. If you can't afford insurance or you don't have a job, why are you having children children?! Social Security was never meant to be used the way it is being used today. When initiated life expectancy of a male was 58yo and social security did not start paying out until 62yo. Meaning that most never recieved a SS check. Thanks to medicine male life expectancy is 73-75yo and the age you recieve SS is 65yo...let's see if you or I recieve a check when we get to 65yo...I highly doubt it.
Dave, I want you to take a look at Texas compared to California. California with it big Government and big taxes/spending is broke...Texas oin the other hand has small Government lower taxes and no state income tax and it is flourishing economically. Why am I bringing this up? Because the democrats have financially ruined California and are now pushing this same agenda to the rest of America while the Republicans have Texas in the right direction. How can Republicans be the party of opposition when until recently the Democrats were unopposed in House?! Democrats haven't done a good job explaining this bill because it's over 2000 pages long and even they don't know fully whats in black and white.
I agree with Angel...scrap this bill and start over. Make C-span present at every meeting. Get both parties on board 50/50 and physicians/PA's/Np's and I would vote for a plan as long as it includes Tort reform and severe penalties for Medicaid/Medicare fraud. It would require that illegals pay out pocket for services rendered or be turned away. People from abroad would not have access to obtain medicaid for medical services as this would have to be covered by their insurance or paid out of pocket. Abortion, which I am not opposed too, cannot be included in Medicaid...American people again have to take RESPONSIBILTY for their actions. If you recieve federal funding/housing then you recieve depo shots to prevent pregnancy and if you become pregnant the checks stop. This is to name but a few...Harsh? Yes, but the American people are tired of paying for citizens that are lazy and cheating the system. As PA's/ NP's and physicians we have made sacrifices to get to where we are through hard work and sacrifice...why should we not expect that of other Americans? A wise man once said, "Ask not what this Country can do for you but rather ask, what you can do for this Country." Well, what happened? |
|
| Jo Ann (Minneapolis, MN) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 5:48 pm |
|
I think that the only way to get our ideas out there is to put together a book/booklet and market it to the general public. We are the future of the healthcare problems and nobody has even taken notice of us a profession. I am an author and publisher with extensive media experience and I, like most of us have ideas that could really help. I think we could do a book or booklet that informs the publc of ideas how these ideas can be implemented. If anyone is interested in pursueing this idea please contact me via e-mail.
joannfriedrich@yahoo.com |
|
| Laura (Jacksonville, FL) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 5:35 pm |
|
| There aren't millions of families without insurance when you take away the illegals and those with plenty of money who CHOOSE not to have health insurance. Health care is not a right like freedom of speech (read the constitution). Just because we are health care professionals does not mean we need to advocate for socialized healthcare, which historically, has not worked in pretty much any other country. Take Canada for instance, their prime minister traveled to the US to get treatment for her breast cancer. HMMM, wonder why she did that? |
|
| Rex Evans (Milford, DE) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 3:29 pm |
|
Angel raises some pretty good points. Where does it all go?
The first reform must be financial transparency. Not just health care but all of our tax revenue usage must be made easily available to the public. It is our money. As I've told my Senators and Representative, decrease my taxes and I can pay my own way in life- don't force me to pay for others who make bad decisions, let me volunteer to help those I deem to be truly needy. |
|
| Bob Blumm (LI. NY) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 2:04 pm |
|
A well thought out and well articulated treatise on a problem that will not disappear and will require professional association as well as professional individuals to respond and address. Unless we pick up the shovels and start filling the sandbags, rouge waves will enter the perimeters and wash this nice idea away entirely.
Bob Blumm, PA-C |
|
| Angel (Milton, FL) |
on 09 Mar 2010 at 1:54 pm |
|
Dave, Glad to see your passion for our patients and what we can provide. My concern is WHERE IS ALL THE MONEY BEING SPENT ON HEALTHCARE GOING?????? It is not going to providers, not going to LTC ( 84Billion is spent for 1.5 Million beds....doesn't go to staff, better beds, food or enough staff.............huge disparity)
Once we have an accurate, unbiased tracking of what happens to the dollars of Medicare and Medicaid, my sense is we will find that there is money in the wrong hands. If we do not look at that we will again spend, but not improve available dollars for care.
I am an FNP-C volunteering provider services at Our Lady of Angels St. Joseph's Free Medical Clinic so we are seeing our numbers of working poor with no health care growing exponentially. The encumbered, obtuse, incestuous Bill that is being "crammed" down the throats of our Congressmen needs to be dissolved, rescinded and given a sanctimonious death.
No health Bill should be adopted by the AMA, when it only represents 17% of our MDs. Healthcare Bills must be written by REAL health Care providers and the TEAMs in the trenches.
I have written and contributed to the writing of many health care bills |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
|